Thatchers’ First Christmas Ad Scores a Perfect 5.9 — Here’s How
Updated: Nov 5
▶ Watch the ad: Thatchers — “Saving Tasting Time” (YouTube)
TL;DR: Somerset cider maker Thatchers released its first-ever Christmas ad this year — and it didn’t just land, it topped the charts. “Saving Tasting Time” scored a perfect 5.9 Stars on System1’s Test Your Ad, the maximum possible and a top-1% result, nearly double its drinks category average. Here’s why a four-generation family brand out-charmed budgets ten times its size.
A first Christmas ad — and a bullseye
For a family business that has been making cider at Myrtle Farm since 1904, waiting 120 years to make your first Christmas ad is a bold way to arrive at the party. Thatchers did exactly that in 2026, and the debut “Saving Tasting Time” went straight to the top of the effectiveness rankings. Independent testing by System1 awarded the spot 5.9 Stars on its Test Your Ad scale — the maximum score, placing it in the top 1% of all ads tested and well ahead of the roughly 3.1-Star average for the beer, cider and flavoured-drinks category.
The numbers behind the headline are just as striking: a Spike Rating of 1.37 (a measure of short-term sales potential), a Fluency score of 89 for instant brand recognition, and 65% of viewers reporting intense happiness while watching. In a season where the big grocers and department stores spend millions chasing exactly those emotions, a regional cider brand beat most of them on the metric that correlates most strongly with long-term growth.
The craft behind the charm
The spot was made with Aardman — the Bristol studio behind Wallace & Gromit — working with agency Bray Leino. Using a blend of stop-motion, puppetry and CGI, it tells a gently high-stakes story set at Myrtle Farm: snow threatens to cancel the traditional Friday 12:30 cider tasting, and the Thatcher family, a hot air balloon and Myrtle the dog rally to save the day. It is warm, hand-made and unmistakably rooted in place — the opposite of a generic festive montage.

That craft is the point. In a year when audiences are increasingly wary of AI-generated and formulaic advertising, Thatchers leaned the other way — into tactile, authored, visibly human-made work. It is the same instinct behind the wider “anti-AI, pro-craft” mood in holiday advertising this year, and it paid off in both acclaim and attention.
What marketers should take from it
First: distinctiveness beats budget. Thatchers didn’t try to out-spend Christmas; it told a specific, ownable story about its own farm and family that no competitor could copy. Second: fame and feeling travel together. The high Fluency and happiness scores show the ad built emotion without losing the brand — the balloon, the farm and the family are all the product’s own assets. Third: craft is a message. Choosing Aardman’s hand-made aesthetic communicated authenticity before a single word was spoken, reinforcing a heritage claim that a slicker, cheaper execution would have undercut.
“This is exactly what effective advertising looks like — distinctive, emotional and unmistakably the brand’s own. A perfect 5.9 is rare, and for a first Christmas ad it’s remarkable.” — Andrew Tindall, Group Chief Growth Officer (Advertising), System1
“We wanted to capture everything we love about Christmas at Myrtle Farm, and working with Aardman let us tell that story with real warmth and craft.” — Martin Thatcher, fourth-generation cider maker, Thatchers
The takeaway: A heritage brand with a clear sense of place and the confidence to make something hand-crafted can out-perform far bigger spenders on the measures that matter. Thatchers’ first Christmas ad is a masterclass in doing less, but doing it unmistakably as yourself.
Related reading
Sources: System1 Test Your Ad; Thatchers Cider; Aardman / Bray Leino campaign materials; UK trade press, November 2026.



