top of page

How Brands Rent Fandom - and What Smaller Businesses Can Borrow

4 hours ago
3 min read
How Brands Rent Fandom - and What Smaller Businesses Can Borrow

Brands increasingly grow by borrowing fandoms they did not build - films, games, characters and creators - and the tactic works when the brand adds something fans actually want, and backfires when it is just a logo tax on a franchise.

What 'renting fandom' means

A fandom is a ready-made audience with attention, emotion and a shared language already in place. Building one from scratch takes years. So brands increasingly rent one: they partner with a film, a game, a character or a creator and borrow its audience for a season. Recent examples run from Dunkin's Marvel tie-in to Jo Malone placing a fragrance inside Fortnite and KFC's 'Bucketverse' rebrand.

The appeal is obvious. A franchise brings built-in reach, emotional heat and cultural relevance that would cost a fortune to generate alone. But rented attention is expensive and temporary, so the economics only work if the brand converts some of it into something lasting - a trial, a sign-up, a memory that sticks after the campaign ends.

When it works, and when it is just a logo tax

The dividing line is whether the brand adds value to the fandom or merely taxes it. A good tie-in gives fans something they genuinely want and could not get otherwise: a limited product, a new way to play, a moment of recognition. A bad one slaps a licence on existing packaging and hopes the logo does the work. Fans notice the difference instantly, and they are unforgiving of brands that show up to extract rather than contribute.

The second test is fit. The partnership should make sense for both sides, so the audience does not feel the brand gatecrashing. When a fragrance house enters a game, or a chicken chain builds a fictional universe, it works because there is a creative logic to it. When the only logic is 'this franchise is popular', the audience smells the desperation.

The SME version of the playbook

You do not need a Hollywood licence to rent fandom. Smaller businesses can borrow local and niche passions: a beloved local team, a regional event, a subculture, or a creator with a small but devoted audience. A micro-influencer with 10,000 obsessed followers is often a better partner than a celebrity with a million indifferent ones, because devotion converts and reach alone does not.

Three rules keep it honest. Pick a fandom whose values genuinely overlap with yours. Add something real - a product, an experience, access - rather than just borrowing the name. And give fans a way to take part, not just something to look at. Do that, and a borrowed audience can become part of your own.

The risk nobody mentions

The danger of renting fandom is dependency. If every campaign leans on someone else's culture, a brand never builds its own. The healthiest approach treats borrowed fandoms as a way to buy time and attention while you invest in the thing that actually compounds: a distinctive brand, a product worth loving, and a community that is yours and not on loan.

Borrowing a fandom is like renting a venue for a great party - it gets people through the door, but if nothing memorable happens inside, they leave with the franchise, not with you. The brands that win use the borrowed crowd to start building a crowd of their own. - Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing

Renting a fandom buys attention; you only keep it if the brand contributes something fans want and uses the moment to build an audience of its own.

When you borrow someone else's audience, what are you giving them that they will remember after the campaign ends?

If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk

Sources: Marketing Minute analysis, with examples from Dunkin', Jo Malone, KFC and Google.

Related reading

Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute

bottom of page
Website by Merx Marketing
Share

⚡ Stay ahead in a minute

The biggest UK marketing stories — and what they mean for your business — every week.

Get the Weekly Digest →
Enter