e.l.f. Made Its First Holiday Ad by Hand — and Deliberately Skipped the AI

For its first-ever holiday campaign, e.l.f. ditched generative AI for painstaking stop-motion — a 60-second film narrated by Alan Cumming that turns 'handcrafted, not artificial' into the whole point.
What e.l.f. actually launched
On 2 November, e.l.f. Beauty released 'e.l.f. Made to Stand Out,' the brand's first dedicated holiday campaign. The 60-second film follows three college-aged friends — Kit, Echo and Cleo — reuniting in their hometown and rediscovering that the quirks they once doubted are exactly what make them stand out. It is narrated by Emmy and Tony winner Alan Cumming and directed by Cami Kwan of Apartment D Films.
The notable production detail is how it was made. Every frame is physical stop-motion — objects nudged and photographed one step at a time — and the team made a point of saying no generative AI was used. e.l.f. says women made up 90% of the puppet team and 100% of the animation team.
Why the 'no AI' flex is the real strategy
This is not a brand that cannot afford AI. e.l.f. built its reputation on being first and loudest on new platforms — TikTok, gaming, Roblox — usually at a fraction of a prestige beauty budget. So choosing the slow, expensive, human way to make a Christmas ad is a deliberate signal, not a limitation.
The timing is pointed. A year after Coca-Cola's AI-generated holiday spots drew a wave of 'soulless' criticism, 'handcrafted' has become a positioning available to any brand willing to show its workings. e.l.f. is effectively arguing that in a feed full of synthetic imagery, the scarce, premium thing is evidence of a human hand.
It rhymes with the brand's data case, too. e.l.f. cited Civic Science research that 68% of US adults say nostalgia influences their purchases — and stop-motion is nostalgia you can see in the texture.
What this means — and what to do about it
The lesson for smaller brands is not 'never use AI.' It is that craft is now a message. If everyone can generate a passable festive scene in minutes, the brands that visibly invest time, texture and real people will read as more premium and more trustworthy — especially to audiences already sceptical of AI slop.
Practically: decide where on the craft-to-automation scale each asset sits. Use AI to move fast on the disposable work — variants, resizes, testing — and reserve the handmade, human-led treatment for your hero moments, where the making is part of the meaning. And if you do make something by hand, say so; the behind-the-scenes is half the campaign.
Quick FAQ
Did e.l.f. use AI in its 2026 holiday ad?
No. e.l.f. deliberately avoided generative AI and made 'e.l.f. Made to Stand Out' with physical stop-motion animation, photographed one frame at a time, and flagged that choice as part of the campaign's message.
Who narrates the e.l.f. holiday campaign?
Actor Alan Cumming narrates the 60-second film, which was directed by Cami Kwan of Apartment D Films.
e.l.f. just reminded everyone that how you made it is now part of what you are selling. AI will handle more of our volume every year — but your hero campaign is exactly where a visible human touch earns trust. Pick your moments to go slow on purpose. — Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing
In a feed flooded with synthetic imagery, visible craft is becoming a premium signal — spend your automation on volume and your human effort on the work that carries the brand.
Would your customers trust a hand-made campaign more than an AI-generated one — and does your brand ever show its workings?
If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk
Sources: Cosmetics Business, Adweek, e.l.f. Beauty, Civic Science.
Related reading
Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute



