top of page

Lloyds' Top Marketer Has a Warning About 'Good Enough' AI - and Your Brand

3 hours ago
3 min read
Lloyds' Top Marketer Has a Warning About 'Good Enough' AI - and Your Brand

As cheap AI content floods every channel, the marketing leadership at Lloyds is making an argument more brands should hear - that just because you can generate it doesn't mean you should - and the brands that thrive will treat AI as a drafting tool, not a publishing one.

The 'good enough' trap

The cost of producing passable content has fallen to almost nothing. That sounds like a marketer's dream, but it has created a new problem the industry has started calling 'AI slop': a rising tide of generic, soulless content that is technically fine and completely forgettable. When everyone can generate 'good enough', good enough stops being good enough.

Senior marketers at Lloyds Banking Group have been unusually candid about this, arguing that the ability to generate content at scale is not the same as a reason to publish it, and warning that careless AI output risks degrading the brand it is meant to serve. For a bank - a category that lives or dies on trust - a flood of hollow content is not a neutral act. It is a slow leak.

Why slop is a brand risk, not just an aesthetic one

Trust is built on distinctiveness and consistency. AI, used lazily, attacks both. It pulls every brand toward the same median phrasing, the same stock cadence, the same 'in today's fast-paced world' openings - a sameness researchers and agencies have started measuring. The IPA's masked tests of AI versus human creative have become a talking point precisely because audiences can often feel the difference even when they cannot name it.

There is a second-order risk, too. As AI-written content fills search results and feeds, platforms and large language models increasingly decide which brands to surface. A brand with a clear, distinctive voice is easier for both humans and machines to recognise and recommend. A brand that sounds like everyone else is easy to ignore - and, increasingly, easy for an AI to leave out of the answer entirely.

A practical framework for using AI without the slop

The answer is not to ban AI; it is to draw a line between drafting and publishing. Use AI generously for the unglamorous middle of the process - research, summarising, first drafts, variations, alt text, meta descriptions. Be far more disciplined about what reaches the audience, where a human should still own the idea, the voice and the final edit.

Three questions keep a brand on the right side of the line. Would we be proud to put our name on this if a customer knew exactly how it was made? Does it sound unmistakably like us, or like anyone? And does it actually say something only we could say? If a piece of content cannot pass those, the fix is not a better prompt - it is a human.

Quick FAQ

What is 'AI slop'?

It is the growing volume of low-effort, generic content produced because AI makes it cheap to generate - technically competent but undifferentiated, and increasingly a drag on brand distinctiveness and trust.

Should brands stop using AI in marketing?

No. The useful distinction is between drafting and publishing: use AI freely for research, drafts and production tasks, but keep human ownership of the idea, the voice and the final edit of anything the audience sees.

AI has made average content free, which means average content is now worthless. The brands that win the next few years will not be the ones that generate the most - they will be the ones with the discipline to publish the least, and to make sure everything they do put out could only have come from them. - Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing

AI should speed up your drafting, not replace your judgement - the brands that publish less but sound unmistakably themselves will win the AI era.

If a customer saw exactly how your last piece of content was made, would you still be proud to put your name on it?

If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk

Sources: Marketing Week, Digiday and the IPA.

Related reading

Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute

bottom of page
Website by Merx Marketing
Share

⚡ Stay ahead in a minute

The biggest UK marketing stories — and what they mean for your business — every week.

Get the Weekly Digest →
Enter