top of page

Maybelline Changes Its 35-Year-Old Tagline — and Only Moves Two Words

5 days ago
2 min read
Maybelline Changes Its 35-Year-Old Tagline — and Only Moves Two Words

Maybelline has rewritten its 1991 tagline from 'Maybe she's born with it. Maybe it's Maybelline' to 'Maybe. We're born with it. Maybe. It's Maybelline' — a two-word change that quietly shifts the line's whole meaning.

What changed

On 11 November, Maybelline updated the slogan it has used since 1991. 'She's' becomes 'we're', and new full stops turn a sing-song jingle into a set of declarations. The line now reads as collective and confident rather than aimed at one admired woman. It anchors a new global platform, 'The Beauty of Infinite Possibility', fronted by Miley Cyrus, with Global Brand President Sandrine Jolly saying the brand is building on its legacy.

Why touch a 35-year-old line at all

Because the meaning underneath it moved. Maybelline points to McKinsey research that over half of global respondents now see beauty as a way to build confidence, against 26% who tie it to looking more attractive or younger. The old line — half compliment, half dig at other women — sits awkwardly with that shift. L'Oreal's Consumer Products division, which houses Maybelline, grew 4.3% like-for-like last quarter; a brand this size changes a famous asset only when the culture has moved under it.

The real lesson: how little they changed

The craft here is restraint. Maybelline kept the cadence, the rhyme and the brand name, and changed only what carried the outdated meaning. Distinctive brand assets — a line, a jingle, a colour — are expensive to build and easy to destroy. The pros don't rewrite them; they edit the smallest possible part and leave the equity intact.

What businesses should do

If you are tempted to refresh a slogan, a logo or a look, start by separating the equity from the problem. What do people actually recognise and love, and what, specifically, no longer fits? Change only the second thing. Most botched rebrands throw away recognition to fix a meaning that a lighter touch would have solved. When in doubt, move two words, not the whole line.

This is how you touch a sacred asset. Maybelline didn't blow up a line people have known for 35 years — it moved two words and kept everything that made it stick. Most rebrands destroy recognition trying to fix meaning. The skill is changing the smallest part that matters. — Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing

Distinctive assets are edited, not rewritten — change the meaning, keep the memory.

If you had to fix your tagline by moving two words, which two would you choose?

If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk

Sources: Marketing Dive, McKinsey, L'Oreal.

Related reading

Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute

bottom of page
Website by Merx Marketing
Share

⚡ Stay ahead in a minute

The biggest UK marketing stories — and what they mean for your business — every week.

Get the Weekly Digest →
Enter