top of page

John Lewis Lands Its Best Christmas Ad Since 2019 — the System1 Verdict

Nov 4
2 min read

Updated: Nov 5

John Lewis Lands Its Best Christmas Ad Since 2019 — the System1 Verdict

TL;DR: John Lewis’s 2026 Christmas ad “Gloria & Pickles” scored 5.6 Stars on System1’s Test Your Ad — the retailer’s best result since Excitable Edgar in 2019, and the fourth year in a row its score has climbed. It’s a clear signal that the Saatchi & Saatchi partnership, and a steadier emotional strategy, are working.

The best score in seven years

John Lewis has owned the emotional centre of British Christmas advertising for over a decade, but the last few years tested that reputation. The 2026 ad — “Gloria & Pickles” — marks the strongest comeback yet, earning 5.6 Stars on System1’s Test Your Ad scale. That is the brand’s highest score since “Excitable Edgar” hit 5.9 in 2019, and it continues a steady four-year climb that tracks almost exactly with the retailer’s decision to settle into a consistent creative partnership. Around 61% of viewers reported feeling happy while watching — roughly double the UK norm.

How it ranks against a decade of John Lewis ads

Placed against the brand’s recent history, the 2026 result sits second only to Edgar — and comfortably ahead of the leaner years of 2021–2023, when scores dipped into the low 3s. The table below ranks the ads by their System1 Star rating:

Year

John Lewis Christmas ad

System1 Stars

2019

Excitable Edgar

5.9

2026

Gloria & Pickles

5.6

2025

Where Love Lives

5.1

2024

The Gifting Hour

4.6

2020

Give a Little Love

4.4

2023

Snapper: The Perfect Tree

3.6

2022

The Beginner

3.3

2021

Unexpected Guest

3.1

The trajectory is the story. After bottoming out in 2021–22, John Lewis has improved its effectiveness score every single year since — 2023, 2024, 2025 and now 2026 — a pattern that rewards consistency over reinvention.

What’s driving the turnaround

Since appointing Saatchi & Saatchi in 2023, John Lewis has stopped chasing a radically new idea each year and instead refined a repeatable emotional formula: a simple relationship at the heart, a gentle twist, and a soundtrack that does heavy lifting. The 2026 ad pairs a grandmother’s “Gran Cave” with a mischievous toy dog, set to Sam Fender’s cover of the Rolling Stones’ “You Can’t Always Get What You Want,” landing on the line “don’t give up on giving.” It is unmistakably John Lewis, and that familiarity is a feature, not a bug — fluency and consistency are exactly what System1’s data rewards.

“Don’t give up on giving.” — John Lewis, “Gloria & Pickles” (2026)

The takeaway: John Lewis’s recovery didn’t come from a bigger idea — it came from sticking with one. Brands chasing a reinvention every season should note that the retailer’s scores only started climbing once it committed to a consistent partner and a repeatable emotional structure. Effectiveness compounds.

Related reading

Sources: System1 Test Your Ad report (linked above); John Lewis & Partners; Saatchi & Saatchi; UK trade press, November 2026.

bottom of page
Website by Merx Marketing
Share

⚡ Stay ahead in a minute

The biggest UK marketing stories — and what they mean for your business — every week.

Get the Weekly Digest →
Enter