top of page

McDonald's Splits Its Top US Marketing Job — a Signal Every CMO Should Read

6 days ago
3 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

McDonald's Splits Its Top US Marketing Job — a Signal Every CMO Should Read

McDonald's has split its most senior US marketing job in two after US CMO Alyssa Buetikofer left following 15 years with the chain — a restructure that arrives amid softening US sales and tells you a lot about where the modern marketing leader's job is heading.

What changed

Buetikofer departs after a decade and a half inside the business. Rather than drop in a like-for-like replacement, McDonald's has divided her remit: global CMO Morgan Flatley adds the interim role of US chief creative officer, while Charlie Newberger steps up as interim senior vice-president and US chief marketing and commercial officer. The company is running a search for a permanent CMO.

The timing matters. The reshuffle lands against a backdrop of softer US sales, and that context reframes the move: this is not a routine succession, it is a company reaching for a different shape of leadership while it works out what it needs.

The real story is in the org chart

Look at how the job was cut in half. One half is creative — brand, storytelling, the stuff that makes you feel something about a Happy Meal. The other half fuses marketing with commercial: pricing, value, menu, the levers that move this quarter's number. McDonald's has, in effect, admitted that one person can no longer own both the long-term brand and the short-term P&L at the scale it operates.

That split is the whole debate about the CMO role made concrete. For years the title has been pulled in two directions — the brand-builder who protects fame and distinctiveness, and the growth operator judged on same-store sales. When a business is under pressure, the commercial half tends to win the budget. Splitting the role is a way of refusing to let one eat the other.

What businesses should take from it

You do not run 13,000 restaurants, but the tension is identical in a team of three. Someone on your side is quietly being asked to be both the brand guardian and the person who hits this month's revenue — and under stress, the revenue job always wins, because it is easier to measure. The discipline McDonald's is buying with two job titles, a smaller business has to buy with two protected blocks of time: one for the work that pays this quarter, one for the brand work that pays in two years. If every marketing hour you spend is justified by this week's sales, you are not building a brand, you are renting demand.

The second lesson is about leadership transitions themselves. McDonald's named interim owners the same day it announced the exit, with clear remits. A vacancy with no owner is where momentum goes to die. When a key person leaves your business, the question customers never see but always feel is: who holds the brand now? Answer it on day one.

Splitting the top job isn't an admission of weakness — it's an admission of physics. You cannot ask one person to protect the brand for the next decade and defend the number for the next 90 days and expect both to win. Small teams feel that exact pull; they just never name it. — Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing

When the brand job and the sales job live in one overworked person, the brand quietly loses. McDonald's just paid for two chairs to stop that happening — protect the equivalent two hours in your own week.

In your business, who actually owns the brand when the pressure is on this quarter's sales?

If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk

Sources: Nation's Restaurant News, The Wall Street Journal, Marketing Dive, Adweek, McDonald's corporate.

Related reading

Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute

bottom of page
Website by Merx Marketing
Share

⚡ Stay ahead in a minute

The biggest UK marketing stories — and what they mean for your business — every week.

Get the Weekly Digest →
Enter