top of page

Does Your Brand Really Have Fans? Probably Not — and That's Fine

6 days ago
2 min read

Updated: 4 days ago

Does Your Brand Really Have Fans? Probably Not — and That's Fine

Klarna's marketing chief David Sandström says too many brands drink the Kool-Aid on the idea of fandom: there are too many brands that believe they have fans or are part of pop culture, and they are just not. He is right, and the delusion is costing money.

The seductive lie

Fandom is the flattering story marketing tells itself: that customers love us, talk about us, want to wear our logo. For a tiny number of brands it is true. For most — especially utility brands people use without seeking out — it is not, and building a strategy on affection that does not exist leads to budget poured into community initiatives, loyalty theatre and culture-chasing the audience never asked for.

Sandström's own example is instructive. He says Klarna does not see itself as having fans; it is a utility. So instead of pretending otherwise, it aims to create ideas big enough that the idea, not the brand, enters the conversation. The brand borrows the attention; it does not demand love it has not earned.

Fame is not the same as fandom

The useful distinction is between fame and fandom. Fame means lots of people recognise you and think of you at the moment of purchase. Fandom means people actively care about you. Fame is what most brands actually need and can realistically build; fandom is rarer, harder, and for a bank, a comparison site or a drinks brand, often beside the point. Chasing fandom you will never have distracts from building the fame you could.

What to do instead

Be honest about which you are. If you are a utility — most businesses are — your job is to be easy to recall and easy to buy: distinctive assets, broad reach, a sharp offer, and the occasional idea big enough to get talked about. Save the community-building energy for the rare categories where people genuinely form identities around the product. For everyone else, the goal is not to be loved. It is to be the obvious, unmissable choice when the need arises — which is a lower bar, and a far more profitable one.

There is enormous pressure on marketers to believe their brand is beloved, because it is a nicer story than people buy us because we are convenient. But convenient, famous and easy to choose is a fantastic place to be. Chasing fandom you do not have burns budget and flatters egos. Building fame you can actually earn pays the bills. — Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing

Most brands do not have fans — they have customers who find them convenient. Build the fame that drives recall and the offer that drives choice; leave fandom to the rare brands that truly have it.

Be honest: does your audience actually care about your brand, or just find it useful — and is your budget spent as if the answer were true?

If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk

Sources: Marketing Week.

Related reading

Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute

bottom of page
Website by Merx Marketing
Share

⚡ Stay ahead in a minute

The biggest UK marketing stories — and what they mean for your business — every week.

Get the Weekly Digest →
Enter