Direct Assurance Breaks From Its Low-Cost Image With a First Brand Film
Updated: 3 days ago
Direct Assurance has launched its first-ever brand film, made with agency Artefact 3000, to shift perceptions from cheap towards service quality — as post-claim satisfaction climbed 11 points to 91.8%.
What Direct Assurance launched
Direct Assurance has released its first-ever brand film, created by agency Artefact 3000, using a wordless "black cat" suspense story to win over 25-to-49-year-olds and reframe the insurer around service quality rather than price. Directed by Tim Bullock, produced by La/Pac and filmed in Vilnius, the spot marks a deliberate move away from the low-cost positioning that has defined the brand.
The timing is backed by data: Direct Assurance says its post-claim customer satisfaction rose to 91.8% in 2026 from 80.8% in 2023 — an 11-point gain that gives the brand a genuine reason to talk about service.
Why it matters
Direct-to-consumer insurers built their businesses on being cheaper. But price is a fragile position — there is always someone cheaper, and "cheap" quietly signals "lower quality" to nervous buyers. Direct Assurance is trying to trade up its brand perception before a rival undercuts it on the only axis it currently owns.
Our read: the smart part is anchoring the rebrand to a real metric. An 11-point jump in post-claim satisfaction is the proof that lets the brand credibly claim service rather than merely assert it. Brand films that reposition on a feeling alone are forgettable; ones backed by a hard number are defensible.
What businesses should do
If you have competed on price, watch for the moment it stops working and start building a second reason to choose you. Service, trust and experience are harder for rivals to copy than a lower sticker — but you can only claim them once you can prove them.
And earn the reposition with evidence. Direct Assurance did not simply decide to look premium; it waited until its satisfaction data justified the story. Before you tell a new brand story, make sure you have the proof point that makes customers believe it.
Quick FAQ
What is Direct Assurance's new campaign?
Its first-ever brand film, made with Artefact 3000, using a wordless 'black cat' story to reposition the insurer around service quality and reach 25-49 year-olds.
What data supports the shift?
Direct Assurance says post-claim customer satisfaction rose from 80.8% in 2023 to 91.8% in 2026, an 11-point gain.
Why move away from a low-cost image?
Price is a fragile position that invites undercutting and signals lower quality; the insurer wants a second, harder-to-copy reason to be chosen.
Competing on price is renting your customers — someone always turns up cheaper. Direct Assurance is right to trade up, and doing it the right way: waiting until an 11-point jump in satisfaction gave it the proof to talk about service, rather than just asserting it. — Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing
Price is a position anyone can undercut — the brands that endure build a second reason to be chosen, and back it with proof before they claim it.
If a rival undercut you tomorrow, what reason beyond price would customers have to stay?
If you would like to know more about this topic, please contact us on danieln@merxmarketing.co.uk
Sources: Influencia, CB News.
Related reading
Written by Daniel Nikolla, Founder of Merx Marketing Ltd and Marketing Minute
Comments